The Upper Room’s Guidelines for the Use of AI in Writing

Artificial Intelligence can be a useful tool for a variety of tasks, yet writers must be especially careful and intentional in their use of AI tools in the work they submit to publishers.

Our faith calls us to be engaged in the world around us to be representatives of Christ’s call for love, justice, and mercy. Ignoring technological advancements such as artificial intelligence does not allow us to best respond to the world around us. Yet this same calling requires us to consider the consequences of such technological advancements and discern how best to use them for our own purposes. Spiritual writing is a uniquely human act. Preserving the practice of writing and the community that participates in reading and writing is an act of faithful service to the work of spiritual development, as well as a contribution to the field of writing in the larger world.

The Upper Room editorial staff believes in the preservation of writing as a spiritual practice. We see this as one of the ways our work helps form the spiritual lives of people around the world. Works published by The Upper Room share real stories of real people with real readers, and the importance of the human element in such communication cannot be overstated. As you write and submit material to The Upper Room, keep these guidelines in mind:

  • Never use AI tools to generate a meditation or a piece of writing in its entirety. At its core, the purpose of writing is communication between one person and another. It is the act of one person made in the image of God reaching out to others across time and space to connect with them. The point of writing a meditation, prayer, or reflection is not the perfection of the thought or the technique but aspiring to achieve the imperfect act of communication with one another and communion with God. Your humanity is essential to this process.
  • Do not use AI to try to make your writing “perfect”. As the widespread use of AI makes content more homogenous, the quirks, subtleties, and stylistic imperfections in human writing have become even more valuable. Our editorial staff works diligently to shape and grammatically perfect the work of our writers as much as possible before publication, but we also understand that your writing is not the same as someone else’s writing, and that’s part of what makes your writing valuable. To put it simply: Write like yourself; we will handle the editing.
  • If you do use AI tools, consider carefully how you do so. Ask yourself: If I were having a friend perform this type of work on my writing, would I still consider it my work? We acknowledge that using AI tools to help you organize your thoughts might be beneficial. Asking AI to help identify holes or points you may have overlooked might deepen your arguments. However, having AI generate content or rewrite your sentences takes the work beyond that of your own. There quickly comes a point at which the work is no longer written in your own voice. This is the point at which AI’s involvement becomes a problem.
  • Information generated from an AI cannot be trusted. Approach purported facts provided by AI tools with suspicion. AI outputs must be vetted and evaluated for factual accuracy as well as implicit bias.
  • Keep track of how you use AI in your work and disclose such use when you submit work to The Upper Room. AI-generated work cannot be copyrighted, so The Upper Room must know what level of involvement AI tools played in the creation of the work so as to correctly apply for copyright protection.
  • The editorial staff of The Upper Room is becoming increasingly skilled in recognizing AI-generated writing and we reserve the right to reject submissions that we deem in our editorial judgment to have been written either partially or entirely by AI.

For more guidance on the use of AI as a writer, visit AI Best Practices for Authors from The Authors Guild.